Foreign Digital Services Trust and Safety Challenges in Indonesia

Foreign digital services operating in Indonesia are facing a critical challenge related to user trust and platform safety. While platforms like TikTok, YouTube, and WhatsApp have high daily engagement, trust in these platforms is still relatively limited. Users are increasingly concerned about data privacy, misinformation, and hate speech.

This challenge becomes more complex due to Indonesia’s strict regulations. Laws like Ministerial Regulation No. 5 (MR5) and the Personal Data Protection (PDP) Law require platforms to quickly remove content and give government officials access to user data. This puts companies in a tight spot; they need to follow local laws while also respecting global principles of free speech and privacy.

To better understand this problem and find real solutions, detailed research was done using AskLumia, an AI-powered research tool.

The Trust Gap Facing Digital Services in Indonesia

AskLumia enables you to research any topic that piques your curiosity. Whether it’s for work, personal curiosity, or business needs, you’ll get comprehensive insights in just minutes.

For this topic, we began the research with a simple prompt: “Evaluate the gap between trust and safety perceptions of foreign digital services among Indonesian users.”

Core Research Findings

To address the core problem of declining trust and regulatory pressure, AskLumia’s analysis integrates internal user perception data with external research on the operational environment. The findings reveal a significant disconnect between user expectations for safety, the actual performance of platform policies, and the complexities of the Indonesian regulatory landscape.

Indonesian users exhibit high daily engagement with foreign digital platforms but maintain only moderate levels of trust, according to internal survey data. This apprehension is primarily driven by significant concerns over data privacy, the prevalence of online scams, and exposure to hate speech and misinformation. This disconnect highlights a critical gap between the platforms’ utility and their perceived reliability in safeguarding users.
Indonesian users exhibit high daily engagement with foreign digital platforms but maintain only moderate levels of trust, according to internal survey data. This apprehension is primarily driven by significant concerns over data privacy, the prevalence of online scams, and exposure to hate speech and misinformation. This disconnect highlights a critical gap between the platforms’ utility and their perceived reliability in safeguarding users.
Foreign digital services operate within a stringent and challenging regulatory environment in Indonesia, as confirmed by external web crawling. Key regulations like MR5 and the ITE Law impose severe operational hurdles, including aggressive timelines for content removal and government access to user data. This framework is often described as enabling digital repression, placing platforms in conflict with global standards of free expression and user privacy.
Across all internal data sources, including digital persona submissions and user surveys, there is a strong and consistent demand for greater localization and transparency. Indonesian users advocate for culturally sensitive content moderation, policies communicated in local languages, and clearer information on data handling practices. This indicates that a one-size-fits-all approach to trust and safety is insufficient for the Indonesian market.

A Framework for Rebuilding Trust and Navigating Regulation in Indonesia

Based on these findings, AskLumia has developed a set of recommendations for foreign digital services. This framework is designed to rebuild user trust by directly addressing safety and privacy concerns while enabling platforms to more effectively navigate Indonesia’s complex regulatory environment.

a. Strengthen User Trust Through Data Privacy Transparency

Platforms should launch a targeted trust-building initiative focused on data privacy and security education for the Indonesian market. This campaign must transparently communicate the specific data protection measures being implemented in compliance with the new PDP Law. Proactively addressing the primary drivers of user mistrust, as identified in internal surveys, will be critical to rebuilding confidence.

b. Improve Content Moderation with a Localized Hybrid Model

It is essential to overhaul content moderation by implementing a hybrid model that pairs AI-driven detection with a significantly expanded team of local human moderators. This team must be deeply trained in Indonesian cultural, political, and social nuances to effectively identify and act on hate speech and misinformation. This approach directly addresses user feedback from internal surveys regarding low satisfaction with current, often automated, enforcement actions.

c. Adopt a Proactive Approach to Regulatory Engagement

Foreign platforms must shift from a reactive to a proactive regulatory engagement strategy by establishing a dedicated policy team in Indonesia. This team should seek clarification on ambiguous aspects of MR5 and the PDP Law and advocate for a balanced approach that protects user rights while ensuring legal compliance. This addresses the operational complexities and compliance uncertainties highlighted in both internal and external research.

d. Deliver a Hyper-Localized Trust and Safety Experience

To meet user demands for localization, platforms must implement a hyper-localized user experience for trust and safety. This includes translating all policy and safety materials into Bahasa Indonesia, creating a local advisory council of experts, and publishing regular transparency reports on moderation actions specific to Indonesia. Such measures would demonstrate a genuine commitment to the local context, as suggested by digital persona submissions.

Balancing User Trust and Regulatory Demands in Indonesia

Foreign digital services in Indonesia are caught between user demands for safety and strict government regulations. People still use these platforms heavily, but trust is gradually declining due to ineffective content moderation. This loss of trust becomes clearer when we look at the day-to-day experiences of Indonesian users.

Indonesian users aren’t casually concerned. They are actively worried about data mishandling and frequently encounter scams and hateful content. When they report these problems, platform responses often leave them frustrated. Meanwhile, platforms must comply with regulations that require quick content removal and provide government access to user data, creating tension between following the law and protecting user rights.

The path forward is clear. Platforms need to invest in people who understand the local context, build real relationships with regulators, and commit to genuine transparency. This includes clearly communicating how data is handled, explaining moderation decisions in ways users can understand, and demonstrating consistent enforcement of policies.

For companies facing similar challenges, such as making sense of conflicting data, understanding what users truly want, and navigating complex regulations, AI-powered research becomes invaluable.

AskLumia uncovered these insights by connecting user feedback, regulatory information, and market dynamics into a coherent story. If you’re facing tough market questions and need to cut through the noise, exploring AskLumia’s capabilities might give you the clarity needed to move forward confidently.

Explore how AskLumia can help you turn complex data into clear and confident decisions.